About Us
Eastern Steel Manufacturing Co.,Ltd is a leading manufacturer and distributor of seamless steel pipe, welded steel pipe, OCTG products and fittings. We supply first-step processing, semi-finished parts and finished parts to help our clients meet fabrication requirements beyond their capacity or to improve operations by moving forward the pre-production processing.
News
In this column you can find the steel pipe related articles you need, including industry trends, product standards and materials, and some technical guidelines.
Services
Eastern Steel Manufacturing Co.,Ltd not only improve product production and sales services, but also provide additional value-added services. As long as you need, we can complete your specific needs together.
Facility
Eastern Steel Manufacturing Co.,Ltd not only improve product production and sales services, but also provide additional value-added services. As long as you need, we can complete your specific needs together.
Projects
Many years of large-scale project experience in various fields（Oil & Gas, Construction, Power Energy, Marine & Offshore, Water Treatment, Exploration & Drilling Services, Pipeline & Petrochemical etc.）, professional project team is responsible from receiving until the end of the project.
Stainless steel heat exchanger tubes, typically manufactured as seamless steel pipes, are widely used in industries such as petroleum, natural gas, water, and steam systems.
In real applications, cracking is rarely caused by a single factor. Instead, it results from the combined effect of temperature fluctuations, chloride corrosion, and material weaknesses.
This guide explains the key causes, typical failure locations, and practical prevention methods.
Quick Cause Overview
| Cause | Impact on Tube |
|---|---|
| Thermal stress | Initiates cracks under cyclic heating |
| Microstructure instability | Creates weak zones and reduces toughness |
| Hydrogen | Causes internal embrittlement and hidden cracking |
| Chloride corrosion | Leads to localized pitting and SCC |
In heat exchanger service, stainless steel tubes are rarely exposed to uniform temperature fields. During start-up, shutdown, or fluctuating operating conditions, rapid temperature changes create significant thermal gradients between the inner and outer walls of the tube, as well as across welded joints and connections.
Because different regions expand and contract at different rates, internal thermal stress is continuously generated and released.
Thermal fatigue is the primary driver of cracking. It is caused by repeated temperature fluctuations rather than external mechanical loads, and typically leads to crack initiation in:
- Welded joints
- Tube-to-tubesheet connections
- Areas with high temperature gradients
Once initiated, these cracks tend to propagate along the direction of maximum thermal stress, and under corrosive environments, they can further evolve into stress corrosion cracking (SCC). This is why, in many real cases, failure is localized rather than uniformly distributed across the entire tube.
For duplex stainless steel heat exchanger tubes, microstructural stability plays a key role in resisting embrittlement. The ferrite–austenite balance is particularly sensitive to alloying elements, especially nitrogen (N).
Nitrogen acts as a strong austenite stabilizer. When its content increases, it may lead to:
- Reduced ferrite phase fraction
- Coarser austenite grains
- Local phase imbalance
In practice, these changes are not always uniform. Localized nitrogen enrichment during manufacturing or welding may create coarse austenite regions.
These zones typically show:
- Lower strength
- Reduced ductility
- Poor resistance to crack initiation
As a result, micro-cracks may form during tube expansion, forming, or early service. Under thermal cycling, these micro-cracks can grow and eventually develop into larger cracks.
In hydrogen-containing service environments (such as petrochemical or refinery systems), stainless steel heat exchanger tubes may absorb hydrogen atoms, especially at elevated temperatures.
These hydrogen atoms diffuse into the metal lattice and can:
- Accumulate at defects, inclusions, or grain boundaries
- Promote the formation of brittle phases (such as hydrogen-induced martensite), which significantly reduces material toughness
- Reduce cohesion between metal atoms
This phenomenon leads to hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC), which is often difficult to detect in early stages because it develops internally before becoming visible on the surface.
A key characteristic of hydrogen-related damage is that cracking may occur even under relatively low external stress. When combined with thermal stress or microstructural weaknesses, hydrogen significantly accelerates crack propagation.
Chloride ions (Cl⁻) are one of the most aggressive factors affecting corrosion resistant stainless steel pipes, especially in heat exchanger environments.
Under elevated temperatures, Cl⁻ can:
- Penetrate and destabilize the passive oxide film on stainless steel surfaces
- Create localized breakdown points (pitting initiation sites)
- Increase the electrochemical activity of the surface
Once the passive layer is damaged, localized corrosion accelerates, leading to pitting or crevice corrosion, which can further evolve into cracking under stress conditions.
In many practical cases, chloride attack does not act alone. It often works in combination with:
- Thermal stress
- Residual welding stress
- Microstructural heterogeneity
This synergy explains why cracking is often observed only in specific areas of the tube rather than uniformly.
Typical Crack Development Path：Thermal fluctuation → Thermal stress → Micro-cracks → Corrosion or hydrogen interaction → Crack propagation → Final failure
Field inspections and failure analyses show that cracking in stainless steel heat exchanger tubes is rarely random. Instead, it tends to concentrate in structurally or thermally sensitive regions.
The most common failure locations include:
Due to differences in microstructure and residual stress, weld zones are inherently more susceptible to both thermal fatigue and corrosion-assisted cracking.
These areas experience high residual stress from mechanical expansion, combined with thermal cycling during operation. Microstructural distortion in this region further increases crack susceptibility.
Sections exposed to uneven heating or rapid temperature fluctuation (e.g., inlet/outlet areas) are prone to repeated thermal stress, making them typical crack initiation sites.
Scaling, fouling, or turbulent flow can create localized overheating or concentration of corrosive species (such as Cl⁻), leading to accelerated degradation.
Thermal embrittlement in stainless steel heat exchanger tubes is typically the result of several factors acting together, rather than a single controllable variable. In practical engineering, prevention is less about “eliminating one cause” and more about reducing the combined effect of thermal stress, microstructural instability, and corrosive conditions.
Among all influencing factors, temperature variation is often the most direct trigger. Rapid heating or cooling introduces internal stress due to uneven expansion, especially across the tube wall and near joints.
In systems with frequent start-up and shutdown, temperature transition becomes a key risk factor. Local thermal gradients are often amplified by poor flow distribution or sudden quenching effects.
In practice, avoiding rapid start-up and allowing gradual heating can significantly reduce thermal stress.
In some systems, improving flow distribution is even more effective, as it helps eliminate local hot spots.
Material performance, particularly for duplex stainless steels, depends heavily on how stable the internal phase structure remains after processing. A nominal grade alone does not guarantee resistance to embrittlement.
When nitrogen content or thermal history leads to coarse austenite regions, these areas tend to behave as weak points under cyclic thermal loading. Similarly, inclusions or compositional segregation can further reduce local toughness.
In practice:
- Control nitrogen content within an appropriate range
- Ensure uniform ferrite–austenite phase distribution
- Apply proper heat treatment after welding or forming
- Avoid materials with segregation or excessive inclusions
The role of surface condition is often underestimated until failure analysis is carried out. Stainless steel relies on its passive film for corrosion resistance, but this protection is highly sensitive to surface quality. If oxide scale, welding residues, or embedded inclusions remain on the surface, they can act as initiation sites for localized corrosion. Once the passive layer is disrupted, crack initiation under thermal stress becomes much more likely.
In practice:
- Remove oxide scale and welding residues after fabrication
- Perform pickling and passivation treatment
- Avoid surface contamination during handling and installation
- Inspect and verify surface quality before service
In many heat exchanger applications, chloride ions play a decisive role in accelerating damage. Their effect becomes particularly severe at elevated temperatures, where the stability of the passive film is already reduced. Rather than acting uniformly, chloride-induced damage is usually localized. Areas with stagnant flow, deposits, or concentration of impurities tend to become the starting points of corrosion. Once localized attack begins, it interacts with existing thermal or residual stress, eventually leading to cracking.
In practice:
- Limit chloride content in working fluid
- Avoid stagnant zones and dead legs in design
- Maintain proper flow velocity to reduce deposits
- Regularly clean fouling and scaling
Q1. What is thermal embrittlement in stainless steel?
Thermal embrittlement is the loss of ductility and toughness due to repeated temperature changes.
It is mainly driven by internal thermal stress and gradual microstructural changes over time.
Q2. Why do stainless steel heat exchanger tubes crack?
Heat exchanger tubes typically crack due to a combination of thermal stress, microstructural instability, and corrosive environments rather than a single cause.
In practice, temperature fluctuations may initiate cracks, while factors like chloride corrosion or hydrogen can accelerate their growth.
Q3. How to prevent stainless steel cracking?
Preventing stainless steel cracking requires controlling both operating conditions and material factors. Reducing thermal cycling, ensuring stable microstructure, and limiting exposure to aggressive media such as chlorides are all important.
In most cases, improving operating stability and environmental control has a more immediate effect than changing materials alone.
Q4. What causes stress corrosion cracking in heat exchanger tubes?
Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is caused by the combination of tensile stress and a corrosive environment, most commonly chloride exposure at elevated temperatures.
It typically occurs in areas with:
- Residual stress (welds, tube expansion zones)
- Thermal stress (temperature fluctuations)
- Poor flow or deposits
SCC can develop without obvious warning and may lead to sudden failure.
Q5. How long do stainless steel heat exchanger tubes last?
Stainless steel heat exchanger tubes typically last 10–20 years under stable operating conditions.
However, service life can be significantly reduced by:
Frequent temperature fluctuations
Chloride or corrosive media
Poor flow distribution or fouling
In aggressive environments, failure may occur within just a few years.
In most real-world cases, cracking in stainless steel heat exchanger tubes is not caused by a single factor. Thermal stress often acts as the initial trigger, while chloride corrosion and hydrogen further accelerate damage.
Attention should be focused on welded joints and expansion zones, where stress concentration and environmental effects are most severe. In practice, improving operating stability and controlling the service environment often delivers better results than simply upgrading materials.
E-mail: sales@eastern-steels.com
