In construction, oil and gas, and fire protection systems, "seamless black steel pipe" and "black iron pipe" are two common and often confused pipe materials. Although they appear similar, both having a black surface, they differ significantly in composition, manufacturing process, performance, and application.

What is Seamless Black Steel Pipe?

Black steel pipe is made from ungalvanized steel and gets its name from the dark, scaly coating of iron oxide on its surface. Because the iron oxide stains its surface dark during the manufacturing process, it is called black steel pipe.

Based on the production process, black steel pipe is mainly divided into two categories: seamless pipe and seam pipe. Seamless black steel pipe refers to seamless steel pipe that has not undergone surface treatments such as galvanizing or painting.

What is Black Iron Pipe?

Black iron pipe is ordinary iron pipe without any surface treatment. Iron pipe before galvanizing is called black iron pipe, and after galvanizing is called white iron pipe. It is also known as water pipe and gas pipe.

Most homes built before the 1960s used black iron pipe for plumbing, such as water and gas pipes. It's a type of steel pipe, but made from a more ductile material.

Black iron pipe is actually a type of steel pipe, but with a slightly different composition, making it more ductile. However, water does corrode this type of pipe more easily than steel pipe.

Differences Between Iron and Steel

The term "steel" is often used as a general term for both steel and iron, but there are differences between them:

Thus, black steel pipe and black iron pipe technically fall under the category of "steel pipe," differing only in carbon content and manufacturing methods.

Seamless Black Steel Pipe vs. Black Iron Pipe: 6 Key Differences

These two types of pipe differ in their applications and ease of use. Beyond that, there are a few other distinctions. Let's discuss their key differences in detail.

1. Composition and Manufacturing

Seamless black steel pipe is made from steel that has not been coated with a base material such as zinc or paint. It is called black steel pipe because its surface develops a dark color due to iron oxidation during the manufacturing process. Black iron pipe is actually made from a low-grade "mild steel" compound. This makes it much more corrosion-resistant than traditional cast iron pipe.

The manufacturing processes used for these pipes also vary. Black iron pipe is produced using a hot-rolling process, while black steel pipe is produced using a cold-forming process. Each manufacturing process has its own advantages and disadvantages.

2. Texture

Seamless black steel pipe has a very smooth surface, which contributes to its attractive overall appearance. You won't see any hairline cracks on these pipes. Black iron pipe, on the other hand, has a rougher texture.

While many people may find the rough texture of black iron pipe acceptable, it detracts from its overall appearance. The rough surface of black iron pipe is susceptible to rust. This is one reason why plumbers prefer black steel pipe to iron pipe.

3. Rust and Corrosion

Unfortunately, black iron pipe is very susceptible to corrosion. When used for water pipes, it can rust both inside and out. Over time, particles from internal rust can seep into the fluids it transports. The main causes of rust are low carbon content and poor joints.

Black steel pipes offer excellent rust resistance. They don't rust quickly; rust takes a long time to show up on the surface. Manufacturers apply a zinc coating to these pipes, galvanizing them. This coating makes them extremely rust-resistant.

4. Repair and Maintenance

The main problem with black iron pipes, especially in homes, is leaks at the joints. Repairing these leaks requires extensive work, which is why many people no longer use black iron pipes. This isn't an issue with steel pipes, which are typically welded.

5. Cost and Affordability

One of the main factors we consider is the price of the pipe. It's safe to say that this factor is a deal-maker. Therefore, black iron pipes are cheaper than comparable products. Compared to black steel pipes, black iron pipes are significantly more affordable.

Seamless black steel pipes typically cost about 20% more than black iron pipes, but in the long run, steel pipes are more energy-efficient and conserve resources. The durability and cost of steel pipe are one reason why it is increasingly used in large industrial projects in the United States.

6. Applications

What are black steel pipes used for?

Black steel pipes are widely used due to their strength and low maintenance.

They are commonly used to transport natural gas and water to rural and urban areas, as well as to protect electrical wires and to carry high-pressure steam and air.

Black steel pipes are also used in the oil industry, transporting large quantities of oil in remote areas. Other uses for black steel pipe include natural gas distribution within and outside homes, water wells, and sewage systems.

However, black steel pipes are rarely used to transport drinking water because they corrode easily in water, and minerals in the pipes can dissolve into the water and clog the pipes.

What are black iron pipes used for?

Black iron pipe is currently one of the best choices for gas piping.

Black iron pipe was once commonly used for water pipes, but since the advent of copper, CPVC, and PEX, it has become increasingly popular for gas piping. It is an ideal choice for gas piping for two reasons: its strength and durability, and its relative ease of assembly.

Like PVC, black iron pipe utilizes a pipe and fitting system that is joined using a composite material rather than welding. Despite its name, black iron pipe is actually made from a low-grade "mild steel" composite material. This makes it far more corrosion-resistant than traditional cast iron pipe.

Simply put, black iron pipe is used for residential natural gas and propane distribution. Black steel pipe is seamless and offers superior fire resistance compared to seamless galvanized pipe, making it more suitable for gas distribution and fire sprinkler systems.

Conclusion

If you're looking for high strength, long life, and industrial reliability, choose seamless black steel pipe. For residential or medium- and low-pressure gas systems, black iron pipe is a cost-effective and practical choice.

Read more:  The difference between erw and seamless black steel pipe